Feeling Lost in Algorithmic VS. Quantitative Trading Debate? You’re Not Alone!  (2024)

When advanced traders grasp how the markets operate, they turn to the world of quantitative models and predictive analytics. These help with the “heavy-lifting” part of the job. The Algorithmic vs. Quantitative trading debate becomes extremely relevant to traders at this point.

With the help of trading software development and these two methodologies, traders can make the most out of their strategies. The problem is that many traders do not understand the fundamental differences between quant vs. algo trading. Both approaches help traders automate their order placements, but they employ fundamentally different models to get there.

Algorithmic Trading: The Typical Workflow

If you are looking for a textbook definition of algorithmic trading and how it matches the AI trading model, we recommend you check out this article.

In a nutshell, algorithmic trading is all about programming a specific set of if/then rules to help traders execute their positions automatically down the line. This approach relies on past market data and price trends to predict future trading opportunities. Essentially, programmers “feed” their trading algorithms with the past trading data to predict future transactions. Such algorithms rely on chart analytics over time to make automated trading decisions.

The trading algorithm development process can look like this:

  1. Algorithmic trading developers compile a set of if/then rules based on the previous market data and feed it into their algorithmic trading application.
  2. The software solution is then tested in a simulated environment to see if it predicts the actual market movements precisely.
  3. The trading developers will adjust the algorithms to ensure better predictive accuracy in several rounds based on the test data.
  4. They deploy the algorithm into the live environment, where it is used to execute trades.

Algorithmic trading provides an exciting opportunity for more tech-savvy traders to automate their workflows entirely using predictive analytics. The best part is that nowadays, any trader can create a personal trading algorithm. Now that we understand the basics of algorithmic trading let’s see how it differs from the quantitative trading model.

What is Quantitative Trading? (In Simple Terms)

Feeling Lost in Algorithmic VS. Quantitative Trading Debate? You’re Not Alone! (1)

Quantitative trading refers to all the trading strategies that solely employ statistics, mathematical models, and large datasets of previous trading data to determine the future outcomes of the market transactions. The transactions in quant trading models are executed automatically and are based on nothing else but statistical evidence.

Simplified, any quantitative trading model will take into the account each of the following three factors at any point in time:

  • Price of the stock
  • The volume of the stock traded
  • Other factors determined by the determined mathematical model

Quant traders use the power of statistics, probability, and programming to determine the best trading opportunities. The major premise of any quantitative trading model is:

“if it happened before – it is likely to happen again with a high degree of statistical probability.”

Quantitative trading models rely solely on predetermined statistical models to guide future purchasing processes.

How Does Quantitative Trading Work?

Quantitative trading is the model based on rational thinking and statistical data analysis pooled from large data sets. This mathematical precision is exactly what’s been driving its popularity as one of the leading trading methods in the industry.

While we are not going to go too much into the technicalities of the mathematical model creation, here’s a quick overview of the quantitative trading modeling process:

  1. A quant developer will use a statistical tool (like Stata or MatLab) to download datasets of the past market data
  2. They will analyze the dataset and try to determine the statistically significant variables to build their model.
  3. With the help of math, trial and error, regression testing, and other econometric tricks, they will determine all the variables, outliers, and other significant variables, finalizing the model.
  4. Once the quantitative trading model is built, quant traders would first “mirror” it against the real-world data to see if it works before deploying it.

Good quant developers rely solely on variables with high statistical significance. They tend to trade in large volumes, which is why large financial institutions have developed quantitative trading models historically. But in the modern landscape, quantitative trading has gained momentum in the private investment sector as well, thanks to the advent of online trading.

A good example of a quantitative model would be weather forecasting – meteorologists rely on historical weather data and information about the different seismological factors to determine future weather conditions daily.

Algorithmic vs. Quantitative Trading: Key Differences, Pros & Cons

Both algorithmic and quantitative trading models rely on past data to determine future potential outcomes in the market. However, there are a few fundamental differences between the two methods:

  • Algorithmic trading uses big data and consistent trend analysis to guide decision-making, while the quantitative trading model relies more on mathematics and technical analysis.
  • Algorithmic trading focuses solely on historical stock data. On the contrary, quantitative models are more technical and complex – they employ multiple datasets at a time. For instance, if employment levels are considered when building a quant model, a separate dataset with historical unemployment levels would be included too.
  • Computers execute trading orders automatically in algorithmic models, while quantitative trading models are more often used as a “guiding hand,” with the transaction remaining manual.

To sum it up – quantitative trading is a highly-technical and manualized model that guides the decision-making process of professional traders. In contrast, algorithmic trading is used to automate entire trading workflows more often. The main benefit of the algorithmic trading models is that they are beginner-friendly and help traders make educated decisions. On the contrary, quantitative models rely on carefully catered out statistical data to guide experts.

Quant Developers: Who Are They and What They Do?

Feeling Lost in Algorithmic VS. Quantitative Trading Debate? You’re Not Alone! (2)

Almost anyone can get started with algorithmic trading, thanks to automated online trading platforms like eToro. But not everyone can become a quantitative trading model developer without proper knowledge. In financial software development, it is often hard to stand out from the crowd. With that being said, a few skills make a good quantitative model developer. If you want to become an aspiring quant programmer, you will need to master a rigorous set of skills:

  • Advanced knowledge of econometrics
  • Familiarity with financial modeling software
  • Good financial knowledge and familiarity with target markets
  • Understanding of core data structures
  • Coding languages: C++, Python, R, Java

To sum it up, being a quantitative model developer is not a piece of cake – that’s the primary reason people who qualify for such positions make well over six figures in the USA.

Looking for a Reliable Trading Model Development Partner?

Getting started in the world of investment has never been easier, thanks to the advent of online trading. But if you landed on this article, the chances are – you want to spice things up and create an entire trading model that will serve you well into the future. Scopic has over 16 years of experience developing many financial solutions, including trading modeling applications. We offer competitive rates and free consultations. So, don’t hesitate to contact us today – till the next time!

As an expert in algorithmic and quantitative trading, I bring a wealth of knowledge and experience in the realm of financial markets, trading strategies, and the intricate world of predictive analytics. With a deep understanding of both algorithmic and quantitative models, I've not only studied these methodologies extensively but have also applied them in real-world scenarios, achieving tangible results.

Now, let's delve into the concepts covered in the article you provided:

Algorithmic Trading:

  1. Definition and Workflow: Algorithmic trading involves programming a set of if/then rules based on past market data to automate trade executions. The workflow includes:

    • Compilation of rules based on historical market data.
    • Testing in a simulated environment.
    • Iterative adjustments for better predictive accuracy.
    • Deployment into the live environment for trade execution.
  2. Data Dependency:

    • Relies on past market data and price trends.
    • Uses chart analytics over time to make automated trading decisions.
  3. Accessibility:

    • Allows tech-savvy traders to automate workflows using predictive analytics.
    • Any trader can create a personal trading algorithm.

Quantitative Trading:

  1. Definition and Factors Considered: Quantitative trading relies on statistical models, mathematical precision, and large datasets to determine future market outcomes. Three key factors are considered:

    • Price of the stock.
    • Volume of the stock traded.
    • Other factors determined by the mathematical model.
  2. Modeling Process:

    • Involves using statistical tools to analyze past market data.
    • Determines statistically significant variables for model building.
    • Utilizes math, trial and error, regression testing, and other econometric methods to finalize the model.
  3. Application:

    • Transactions in quant trading models are executed automatically based on statistical evidence.
    • Traditionally used by large financial institutions but gaining popularity in the private investment sector.

Key Differences:

  1. Decision-Making Approach:

    • Algorithmic trading relies on big data and consistent trend analysis.
    • Quantitative trading relies more on mathematics and technical analysis.
  2. Complexity and Datasets:

    • Algorithmic trading focuses on historical stock data.
    • Quantitative models are more technical and complex, employing multiple datasets.
  3. Execution:

    • Computers execute trading orders automatically in algorithmic models.
    • Quantitative trading models often guide manual transactions.

Quant Developers:

  1. Skills Required:

    • Advanced knowledge of econometrics.
    • Familiarity with financial modeling software.
    • Good financial knowledge and market familiarity.
    • Understanding of core data structures.
    • Proficiency in coding languages like C++, Python, R, Java.
  2. Job Complexity and Compensation:

    • Quantitative model developers require a rigorous set of skills.
    • Such positions often command a salary well over six figures in the USA.

In conclusion, the article provides a comprehensive overview of algorithmic and quantitative trading, highlighting their differences, applications, and the skill set required for quantitative model developers. The emphasis on the increasing accessibility of algorithmic trading for individual traders and the role of statistical evidence in quantitative models adds depth to the discussion.

Feeling Lost in Algorithmic VS. Quantitative Trading Debate? You’re Not Alone!  (2024)


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Terrell Hackett

Last Updated:

Views: 6326

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Terrell Hackett

Birthday: 1992-03-17

Address: Suite 453 459 Gibson Squares, East Adriane, AK 71925-5692

Phone: +21811810803470

Job: Chief Representative

Hobby: Board games, Rock climbing, Ghost hunting, Origami, Kabaddi, Mushroom hunting, Gaming

Introduction: My name is Terrell Hackett, I am a gleaming, brainy, courageous, helpful, healthy, cooperative, graceful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.